Students preparing for medical school interviews should have a good grasp of various hot topics that can be applied to their answers. The issue of NHS Privatisation and Private Healthcare in the NHS is one such topic and will be discussed in this article.
An overview of the NHS in its current form will be given, as well as the pros and cons of NHS Privatisation and how this could come up in medical interviews.
Combine your reading here of medicine interview questions and model answers with medicine interview tutoring or 1-1 mock interviews to ensure even greater success in your interviews.
Summary of NHS Privatisation in the UK for Medical Interviews
The NHS was created to provide universal healthcare that is free to all who need to access it.
It has been argued that in recent years, NHS spending on the private sector has increased.
Some NHS services are already provided by the private sector, such as dental, optical and pharmacy services.
There are arguments both for and against privatisation of the NHS, which focus on the current waiting lists in the NHS, the transparency of private companies with consumers, patient choice, efficiency and fairness.
It is important to understand what NHS privatisation is, the ethical considerations of this issue, the pros and cons, and how to answer questions on it for your interview.
👉🏻 Read more: Ultimate Medicine Interview Preparation Guide
NHS Background and Overview for Medicine Interviews
It is important for you to have a basic understanding of how the NHS is structured and how it operates:
The NHS dates back to 1948 and employs approximately 1,093,000 people. It was created to ensure free healthcare for all.
Any UK resident can use NHS services for free. However, prescriptions, dental services and optical services are charged-for areas of the NHS (with some exceptions).
Optical, dental and pharmacy services are provided by the private sector. Most GP practices are also private organisations which have partnerships with the NHS.
The NHS is funded by the Department of Health budget. The money from this budget comes mostly from general taxation of the public.
It is important to remember that there is NOT an NHS across the UK. It is split into four health bodies: England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.
The NHS is made up of these national bodies, as well as other organisations like Integrated Care Systems, primary care organisations, acute trusts (hospitals), mental health trusts, community trusts, ambulance trusts and also charities.
👉🏻 Read more: NHS Core Values
What does it mean to privatise the NHS?
Privatising parts of the NHS would mean the offering of contracts to private companies. These companies would then run certain services.
As stated in the section above, some services have always been provided by the private sector. There are partnerships between the NHS and private organisations to deliver services other than the ones mentioned so far, like radiology and even car parking. Therefore, it is not a “new” phenomenon for the NHS to use private organisations for some of its services.
However, in recent years, the NHS has turned to using private organisations in a slightly different capacity. This includes using private hospitals for the deliverance of NHS care, due to the need for care from the public outweighing the current capacity of the NHS.
This type of partnership with private hospitals was seen to a substantial degree in the COVID-19 pandemic, as more resources like beds and staff were needed to deal with the crisis. The spending by the NHS on private sector services in 2020/21 was £12.2 billion.
This figure can be compared to NHS spending on private sector services in 2019/20 at £9.7 billion. The figures pre and mid-pandemic do differ by a lot, however, they both represent approximately 7% of the Department of Health and Social Care budget for both those years (the budget increased in 2020/2021 to cater for the costs of the pandemic).
Although the percentage of the budget spent on private sector services has remained at a similar level in the last few years, the current pressure on the NHS means that there has been lots of discussion on how its relationship with the private sector may change in the future.
Furthermore, research has demonstrated that over a longer period (from 2013), the outsourcing of services to private companies has increased.
👉🏻 Read more: Common NHS Hot Topics
NHS Privatisation Pros and Cons
Privatisation of the NHS is a very complex topic, on which people have various opinions. Therefore it is important to remember that debate on this topic goes beyond the pros and cons listed below.
Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
Patients will have more choice to choose their treatments, and where they want to receive them | Public healthcare is actually more efficient in providing care than private healthcare |
It could help with the current waiting lists within the NHS | Continuity of care is not as likely if private companies are running health services, as profits will be the main motivator |
The NHS is currently experiencing great stress, and privatisation could alleviate some of this | The public system is fairer |
Less time-wasting as patients would not be able to be seen for free and thus would only seek healthcare if entirely necessary | Private companies would likely be less transparent with the consumer than the public sector, as is seen in other countries with private healthcare models |
👉🏻 Read more: NHS GP Shortage and Crisis
Ethical Considerations of Privatisation of the NHS
Like with all hot topics that may arise in medicine interviews, ethical considerations should be discussed. NHS Privatisation is a highly contentious topic and therefore, the ethical aspects of it may help you to discuss it in an interview setting.
Autonomy: Privatising the NHS could give patients more choice in their healthcare, by allowing them to decide which doctor is best for them, where they would like to be treated and what treatment they wish to receive. However, not everyone may be able to access healthcare in the same way if the NHS is privatised, and thus this restricts their autonomy.
Beneficence/non-maleficence: These principles are a bit more difficult to discuss, as they are heavily influenced by opinion when it comes to privatisation. It could be argued that removing the huge waiting lists by outsourcing procedures to private companies is good, however, many will see this as harmful because of the lack of transparency and questionable motives of private companies.
Justice: The NHS as a healthcare system free to all at the point of access encompasses the principle of justice. Therefore, the divide that could result from privatising the NHS would oppose this principle.
👉🏻 Read more: Answering Medical Ethics Questions
Impact of Private Healthcare on Medical Students and Doctors
According to a BMA survey, two-thirds of doctors are uncomfortable with the privatisation of the NHS. The BMA and doctors alike are concerned with the motives for privatisation of the NHS.
Although it is not entirely understood how privatisation would affect healthcare professionals, the current lack of support by doctors may suggest that there would be dissatisfaction with their workplace if privatisation were to occur. Thus, this may lead to more leaving their profession.
Furthermore, if privatisation were to occur in various areas within the NHS, the structure of the health system could become fragmented and harder to navigate for healthcare professionals.
However, privatisation could provide the possibility for healthcare professionals to earn more money, if they decided to work for certain private companies over others.
Privatisation would also affect medical school teaching, as placements in hospitals or certain services would not be as straightforward.
These are some possible ways that privatisation could affect doctors and medical students. However, its full impact is unlikely to be understood before the privatisation of aspects of the NHS.
👉🏻 Read more: Junior Doctor Contract
Preparing for a Medicine Interview: NHS Privatisation
In the post-COVID era of medicine, privatisation is a topic which could easily arise in a medicine interview.
It is most likely that you would be asked about the advantages and disadvantages of privatisation in the NHS. It would also be expected of you to know that dental, optical, GP and pharmacy services are mostly provided by private services in the NHS.
This is a difficult topic, however, so do not worry if you don’t entirely understand every aspect of privatisation. It is important that you can demonstrate a balanced view on privatising the NHS if asked about it, and demonstrate some understanding of how privatising services would change the NHS.
👉🏻 Read more: Medicine Interview Topics
Medicine Interview Questions on NHS Privatisation
What are your views on privatising the NHS?
How do you think privatisation of the NHS would impact those working in it?
What are the advantages of private healthcare in the NHS?
What are the disadvantages of privatising the NHS?
How do you think medical students would be affected by the privatisation of the NHS?
Discuss some of the ethical considerations of privatising the NHS.
Discuss the impact of privatisation on the cost of care for patients.
What role should private companies play in publicly funded healthcare systems like the NHS?
Is privatisation of the NHS following the principle of justice?
Some argue that privatisation would be good for the NHS because patients would be deterred from seeking healthcare for minor issues that do not need professional treatment. What do you think of this argument?
How would the increased involvement of private companies affect the quality of NHS services?
What potential implications would NHS privatisation have on universal healthcare in the UK?
How would the changing relationship between the NHS and the private sector affect healthcare accessibility for UK residents?
Do you believe the growth of private sector services within the NHS is a stepping stone to full privatisation?
How could the privatisation of the NHS influence the future landscape of medical education and training in the UK?
👉🏻 Read more: 280 Medical School Practice Interview Questions
How to answer questions on NHS Privatisation in Medicine Interviews
The three most important things to consider when answering questions about NHS Privatisation in your interview:
If asked about your view on privatisation, make sure you give a balanced argument to demonstrate you understand both the advantages and disadvantages of privatisation.
Make sure you have a basic understanding of the structure of the NHS, as this will help you with understanding how private companies relate to the NHS currently.
Remember that you are applying to medical school to become a doctor, and therefore your answers to these questions should hold the patient as the most important concern when it comes to privatisation. That is not to say that appreciation for the economics within the NHS is not needed, it is just more in line with your future role as a doctor to focus on patient care.
👉🏻 Read more: MMI Medicine Interview Tips Guide
Interview model question and answer: NHS Privatisation
Q: Is privatisation of the NHS following the principle of justice?
A: The principle of justice is one of the four main principles of medical ethics. These principles are sometimes referred to as the four pillars of medical ethics. They play a very important role in medicine and the NHS.
When employing the principle of justice, healthcare professionals are ensuring that patients are treated fairly and that treatment and care are given based on need and not any other factors.
The principle of justice was at the heart of the NHS when it was created, as it ensured that access to this healthcare organisation was not based on whether someone could afford it or not.
Privatisation of areas of the NHS could lead to patients having to pay for certain treatments or procedures. This conflicts with the concern that the NHS has for providing care to all, regardless of wealth, and thus seems inconsistent with the principle of justice.
Therefore, I argue that the privatisation of the NHS is not following the principle of justice.
👉🏻 Read more: Medicine Interview questions guide
FAQs on Private Healthcare & The NHS
What happens if the NHS is Privatised?
Private companies will take over certain services if the NHS is privatised. This could potentially mean patients have more choices in their treatments and the locations where they want to receive them. However, there may be concerns regarding the transparency of private companies, as well as the possibility of increased healthcare costs for patients.
What is an example of NHS privatisation?
An example of NHS privatisation is the partnership between the NHS and private hospitals to deliver care. This was seen during the COVID-19 pandemic when the NHS needed more resources like beds and staff to handle the crisis. In such instances, private sector involvement increased to cope with demand.
Should we privatise the NHS?
The decision to privatise the NHS is subjective and depends on various factors. While privatisation might help with current waiting lists and give patients more choices, there are concerns about transparency, continuity of care, and a potential increase in healthcare costs for patients.
Should the NHS be Privatised pros and cons?
The pros of NHS privatisation include potentially more patient choice and help with waiting lists, and some argue that it could alleviate stress on the NHS. The cons include a potential decrease in transparency with patients, reduced continuity of care due to profit motives, and it could lead to a less fair healthcare system.
How would NHS privatisation impact healthcare professionals?
Privatisation of the NHS could lead to a fragmented health system that could be difficult for healthcare professionals to navigate. While it might offer opportunities for higher earnings for those who work with certain private companies, the overall dissatisfaction with workplace changes might lead to more professionals leaving their jobs.
How could NHS privatisation impact medical students?
NHS privatisation could affect medical students as the structure of their placements could change. If different services are run by private companies, placements could become more complex and harder to organise.
What is the public opinion on NHS privatisation?
Public opinion on NHS privatisation is mixed. While some see potential benefits such as improved efficiency and patient choice, others worry about decreased transparency, disruption of continuity of care, and the potential for increased healthcare costs.
Is NHS privatisation in line with medical ethics?
Opinions on this matter vary. Privatisation could potentially enhance patient autonomy by providing more choices. However, it may conflict with the principles of justice if it leads to unequal access to care based on the ability to pay.
How much does the NHS spend on private sector services?
In the fiscal year of 2020/2021, NHS spending on private sector services was £12.2 billion, increased from £9.7 billion in 2019/2020. These figures represent about 7% of the Department of Health and Social Care budget for those years.
How has the relationship between the NHS and the private sector evolved?
The NHS has always utilised private sector services to a certain extent, for example in dental, optical and pharmacy services. In recent years, due to pressures on the NHS, the extent of these partnerships has grown, with private hospitals being used to provide NHS care when demand outweighs current capacity.
Conclusion
NHS Privatisation is an important topic for you to be aware of when preparing for interviews. Questions on this topic provide an opportunity for you to demonstrate your understanding of medical ethics, and the structure of the NHS, and also showcase your ability to give a balanced view on a controversial subject.
Get 1:1 Tutoring today from expert interview tutors for both Panel & MMI Interviews
See our Trustpilot reviews here
Check out our Medicine Interview Tutoring and Interview Question Bank which has over 400 medicine questions and answer guides for your practice.
This is amazing, thank you so much